So you’ve decided it’s time to hire an SEO consultant.
Maybe your website isn’t ranking the way you hoped. Maybe you’re tired of watching competitors dominate Google while your beautifully designed site collects digital dust. Or maybe you just know, deep down, that you’re leaving money on the table by not investing in search engine optimization.
Whatever brought you here, we get it. Finding the right SEO consulting partner is one of the most important decisions you’ll make for your business. The right consultant can help you attract qualified leads, increase visibility, and grow your revenue. The wrong one? Well, let’s just say there are a lot of “experts” out there who are happy to take your money and deliver very little in return.
Before you sign on the dotted line, here are 10 things you absolutely need to know when searching for SEO services for small business owners like yourself.
1. Experience Matters More Than Degrees
Here’s something that might surprise you: according to industry data, less than 30 percent of SEO job postings require a degree, and nearly two-thirds have no degree requirements at all. That’s because SEO is a field where hands-on experience, adaptability, and proven results carry far more weight than a diploma.
When evaluating an SEO consultant, ask about their track record. Have they worked with businesses similar to yours? Can they show you case studies or examples of rankings they’ve improved? A consultant with five years of real-world experience will almost always outperform someone with a marketing degree but no practical knowledge of how search engines actually work.
2. Beware of “Guaranteed Rankings”
If an SEO consultant promises you the #1 spot on Google, run the other way. Seriously.
No one: not even the most talented SEO professional: can guarantee specific rankings. Why? Because Google’s algorithm considers hundreds of factors, and those factors change constantly. According to Google’s own guidelines, no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.
A trustworthy consultant will set realistic expectations, explain their strategy, and focus on sustainable growth rather than quick fixes that could get your site penalized.
3. Understand What SEO Consulting Actually Includes
3. Understand What SEO Consulting Actually IncludesSEO isn’t just about stuffing keywords into your content and hoping for the best. A quality SEO consultant will typically offer:
- Technical SEO audits to identify issues with site speed, mobile-friendliness, indexing, and crawlability
- Keyword research using professional tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Moz
- On-page optimization for content, meta tags, headers, and internal linking
- Off-page strategies including link building and reputation management
- Analytics and reporting through Google Analytics and Google Search Console
Before hiring anyone, make sure you understand exactly what’s included in their services: and what isn’t.
4. Local SEO Is Different From General SEO
If you’re a small business serving a specific geographic area, you need someone who understands local SEO. This involves optimizing your Google Business Profile, building local citations, earning reviews, and targeting location-specific keywords.
Not every SEO consultant specializes in local search. If your goal is to attract customers in your city or region, make sure you’re working with someone who has specific experience in this area. The strategies that work for a national e-commerce brand won’t necessarily work for a law firm in Tampa or a boutique in Brooklyn.
5. Transparency Is Non-Negotiable
A good SEO consultant will never hide behind jargon or keep you in the dark about what they’re doing. You deserve to know:
- What strategies they’re implementing
- Why they’re making specific recommendations
- How they’re measuring success
- What results you can realistically expect: and when
If a consultant can’t explain their approach in plain English, that’s a red flag. SEO isn’t magic: it’s strategy, data, and consistent effort. You should always understand what you’re paying for.
6. Budget Wisely: But Don’t Go Cheap
Let’s talk money. The median salary for SEO consultants in the U.S. is around $92,000, which gives you some perspective on what quality expertise costs. If someone is offering SEO services for $99 a month, ask yourself: what kind of work can they realistically deliver at that price?
Cheap SEO often means automated reports, spammy backlinks, and cookie-cutter strategies that can actually hurt your rankings. Quality SEO services for small business require time, expertise, and personalized attention: and that comes at a fair price.
Think of it as an investment, not an expense. The right consultant will pay for themselves many times over through increased traffic and conversions.
7. Look for Someone Who Understands Your Industry
Generic advice only gets you so far. The best SEO consultants take time to understand your specific industry, your competitors, and your target audience. They’ll research what keywords actually matter for your business: not just what has high search volume.
At Nora Kramer Designs, we believe in strategy before design. That means we never start with tactics. We start by understanding your business goals, your customers, and what success actually looks like for you. Only then do we build a plan that makes sense.
8. SEO Is a Long-Term Commitment
If you’re looking for instant results, SEO probably isn’t the right fit: at least not as your only strategy. Search engine optimization is a marathon, not a sprint. It typically takes 3-6 months to start seeing meaningful improvements, and ongoing effort is required to maintain and build on those gains.
A reputable consultant will be upfront about this timeline. They’ll also help you understand that SEO works best when combined with other efforts like quality website design, content marketing, and a solid user experience.
9. Communication Style Matters
You’re going to be working closely with your SEO consultant, so make sure their communication style meshes with yours. Do they respond to emails promptly? Are they willing to hop on a call when needed? Do they explain things in a way that makes sense to you?
The best partnerships are built on clear, consistent communication. If you feel confused, ignored, or talked down to during the initial consultation, imagine how frustrating it will be six months into a contract. Trust your gut: and choose someone who feels like a true partner, not just a vendor.
10. Strategy Should Come Before Tactics
This is perhaps the most important thing to know: good SEO starts with strategy.
Too many consultants jump straight into tactics: tweaking title tags, building random backlinks, churning out blog posts: without first understanding the bigger picture. But tactics without strategy is just noise. You might see some short-term bumps, but you won’t build sustainable visibility.
The right SEO consultant will take time to audit your current situation, research your competition, identify opportunities, and develop a customized roadmap. They’ll prioritize the actions that will have the biggest impact on your specific goals.
At Nora Kramer Designs, this philosophy guides everything we do. We’re not interested in churning out generic reports or implementing the same cookie-cutter strategy for every client. We believe in personalized service and thoughtful, intentional work that actually moves the needle.
Ready to Find the Right SEO Partner?
Hiring an SEO consultant is a big decision: but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By knowing what to look for (and what to avoid), you can find a partner who genuinely understands your business and is invested in your success.
If you’re a small business owner looking for SEO consulting that’s strategic, transparent, and tailored to your needs, we’d love to chat. Get in touch with us and let’s talk about how we can help your website work harder for your business.
- Looking For an SEO Consultant? Here Are 10 Things You Should Know First - January 27, 2026
- Local SEO Services: How to Get Found in Your Own Backyard - January 26, 2026
- WordPress Maintenance Matters: What Most Small Business Owners Get Wrong - January 26, 2026
